Saturday
Oct152011

"Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books

Check out the source of this piece here, where it is accompanied by an excellent essay on the same subject by Jasper Bernes, Joshua Clover and Annie McClanahan. In the meantime, here's my bit:

They are occupying Riverside! They’re occupying Oakland and Omaha and Iowa City and Sacramento and Denver and Miami and Kalamazoo and and Hartford and Philadelphia and Buffalo and Austin and San Antonio and Fort Wayne, Indiana! On Tuesday morning, police in Boston arrested 141 protesters. This week cops made mass arrests in Des Moines, grabbing 30 in one swoop, plus 25 in Chicago, 11 in San Francisco, six in DC, another 21 in Seattle last week, and those 700 on the Brooklyn Bridge. Torrance is under occupation!

What a difference a month can make. Until September 17, 2011, I was buzzing along in my usual slow, steady state of localized political despair. In Tunisia, Egypt, Syria, Libya, Yemen, and Bahrain, people had been risking and losing their lives, demanding to play a role in the construction of their own societies. And it was clear enough, if you paid attention, that they were rising up not just against particular dictatorships but against the local manifestations of a global economic system that had for decades been concentrating wealth in fewer and fewer hands, privatizing all public goods, tossing everything into the market and dicing it up into speculation-ready bits. The Greeks took to the streets, too — and the Chileans, the Italians, the Spanish, the French, the Irish, the British, the Icelanders. The forty-years-and-running neoliberal transfer of public wealth to private coffers was everywhere becoming too brutal and too brazen to ignore. While mouthing the now nearly universal rhetoric of “shared sacrifice,” governments were feeding billions directly to the banks. And people across the planet were showing them exactly what they were willing to sacrifice — their freedom, their lives — to stop the looting.

Everywhere but here. In the U.S., it seemed that Milton Friedman’s jolly acolytes had colonized (occupied, even) not only the halls of power but our very imaginations, locking us into solitary suffering, cutting off all possibility of even envisioning some collective response. Politics was for politicians — and for those who could afford to buy one. Even the fleeting, expiatory pleasures of a good riot seemed beyond us. We were pissed, surely and righteously, but beyond voting-booth fetishism, online griping, and The Secret, what options did we have? The jackals in Congress wouldn’t listen anyway. They had their orders. Better to stay home, avoid the mailman while there still was one to avoid, and pray that the Law of Attraction kept functioning long enough to keep the cable and the Internet on.

It took the Canadians, in the end, to snap us out of it. I didn’t know Adbusters was still around, but a few people did, and they began to gather in a tiny park in lower Manhattan near a certain street with a famous name, a name that spoke, appropriately, of exclusion, fortification, enclosure. There were not many people out there at first, but there were enough, apparently, to make certain other people nervous. People of the exclusive, enclosed and well-fortified variety. For the next two weeks, the mainstream press kept a studious silence while Mayor Bloomberg and the New York Police Department did everything they could to turn an isolated protest into a rapidly growing movement. Every blast of pepper spray, every baton blow to the gut, every protester beaten and dragged away on YouTube made it clear what the stakes were, and who was on what side. While the slogan of the moment — “We are the 99 percent” — can be faulted for eliding enormous differences of class, race and privilege among us masses of non-billionaires, billy clubs and zip-tie cuffs have a funny way of forging solidarity. The fallen and falling middle class is swiftly learning what the poor have known for too long: that the rich protect their wealth with violence and the state exists to help them do it. Like the picket signs say: “Screw us and we multiply.”

In Los Angeles, the police have maintained an anomalously light touch. Most of the times I’ve visited the occupation site outside City Hall, I did not see a single police officer. They surely saw me: the new LAPD headquarters, with its cameras and mirrored glass, is right across the street. And our local politicians have been cleverer than New York’s. Rushing to bask in the movement’s populist glow, the City Council yesterday passed a resolution endorsing the occupation. When it rained last week, Mayor Villaraigosa wandered the encampment, distributing ponchos, shaking hands, undoubtedly grinning his 100-watt grin. Some activists have fretted about co-optation, worrying that the Democratic Party and the union bureaucracies will contain and ultimately kill off the rising insurgent energy. But no one I’ve spoken with on the City Hall lawn has seemed in any danger of being satisfied.

The more immediate hazard may come from a different kind of comfort. Last week, the Slovenian philosopher and academic superstar Slavoj Žižek made an appearance in New York’s Zuccotti Park, where he warned his acolytes among the protesters not to be satisfied with “carnival.” On first glance, this seemed a bit curmudgeonly. Part of the point of this sort of occupation is to reclaim public space, to encourage the sort of noncommercial relationships between human beings discouraged by corporate culture, to build in miniature the society you are fighting to create. This means taking care of one another. It means all the unlikely things that protesters in New York and L.A. and elsewhere are already doing: Setting up free kitchens and libraries and childcare and open air schools and why not a bike repair tent too, and what rudiments of health care people can provide for one another on a small patch of grass. It means drum circles, if we really must. It means not just chanting and marching together but dancing a little, and arguing too. Anarchists and liberals aren’t supposed to agree, but better that they figure out how and to what extent they are willing to work together than that everyone simply stay home. Fighting, too, is carnival. And especially here in Los Angeles, where public space is most often experienced with one’s foot on the brake at rush hour, we could use a bit of carnival, a chance to live in the spaces that are allegedly ours without an entrance fee or corporate sponsorship.

Still, Žižek was right. If the cops are being polite and the politicians are eager to make the protesters comfortable, it’s not because they’re nice. It’s because they’re not feeling sufficiently threatened. When several hundred protesters left the City Hall campsite last week, marched to a Bank of America branch on Figueroa, and refused to leave until tellers cashed a giant, Ed McMahon-style check for $653 billion made out to the people of California, the chumminess of our brothers in blue evaporated. Eleven people were arrested. The lesson was clear: The protests would be permitted, encouraged even, so long as the protesters didn’t try to actually do anything. It’s not a fight, in other words, unless you’re fighting. Otherwise, as one particularly intense young fellow put it to me on the City Hall steps last night, “We’re just fucking camping.”

 

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (42)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: sarals.com
    Ive meant to write about something like this on one of my blogs and this has given me an idea. Cheers.
  • Response
    This unique feature makes it incredibly suitable for dealing with unclean bodies of drinking water which include what occurred in the Peconan River basin. Within this case, the air pollution didn't just take place within the drinking water but in the sea bed at the same time. Draining from the water ...
  • Response
    Response: parka med pels
    Horse back lovers also enjoy applying tipis since they can be quite mobile. 1 can use them for trailblazing in year spherical situations. A number of consumers usually do not look into their horseback riding trip comprehensive until they've been capable to commit the night in a teepee.
  • Response
    I recently invested a while revising my private vision/mission statement for my coaching apply. Whilst doing this, it transpired to me that the vision I have for my work is intently associated to my private eyesight. Obtaining a career that displays my private vision is powerful since it has permitted me ...
  • Response
    Response: iLHPKkLU
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: argyle ugg boots
    Plenty of top Ford executives evidently regard the loved ones as not-very-shrewd owners who've contributed little for the company's prosperity. One industry personal says that Ford executives ''have full and total disdain'' for that family members and can visit any intense to prevent displaying favoritism. Petersen flatly denies any this kind ...
  • Response
    Response: sac lancel rose
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: moncler cazadoras
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Link K Schwartz
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Laura Glading
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Laura Glading
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Laura Glading
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: freedom mentor
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: freedom mentor
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    On zbawi wszystkich. Działają prochy. Zbawi on miasta i zbawi wiochy, Zbawi miasteczka i zbawi sioła,
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: Frank Dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: frank dellaglio
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: USHUD
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: USHUD
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: qwe8
  • Response
    Response: York
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    Response: makeup brushes
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books
  • Response
    ben ehrenreich - Blog - "Welcome to the Occupations" from the Los Angeles Review of Books

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>
« Enjoy the Ride | Main | The mood is jubilant. »